Evidence Hunter activity pack
This handy activity pack for 11-14 year olds gives kids the skills and confidence they need to critically assess stories and claims they see and hear [...]
The Evidence Hunter activity pack empowers young people to ask, ‘What is the evidence behind this claim?’ It aims to help them develop the skills and confidence needed to critically assess claims they come across online and reduce the spread of false information.
The pack was designed for kids aged 11 to 14, to be used in an informal setting like an after-school club or Scouts or Guides group – but it can be run by any adult with just one child or in a small group.
We had a lot of help from kids putting together this pack, which is probably why it has been so popular. The hands-on activities are based on real-life claims about products and lifestyle choices. Examples range from claims about the benefits of products such as charcoal toothpaste and caffeine shampoo, to the impact of lifestyle choices such as the effect of social media use on sleep or whether helping others really does make you happier. By taking part and learning to ask new questions about evidence and sources, young people develop their critical skills and gain the confidence to ask the right questions. It's a great way to kick start a conversation about evidence with your child or a group of kids.
The Evidence Hunter Activity pack is easy to follow: all you need to run through the activities is a print-out of the pack and a set of counters or tokens, such as Post-It notes. The pack includes guidance on different types of evidence and how you can help your child or a group of kids to think critically about the claims they see and hear in everyday life.
Please get in touch with any questions and to let us know what you think of the pack.
This exercise looks at to what extent we trust different kinds of claims that are commonly found online and in the media, and why. Participants are presented with five claims, and asked to place ‘trust’ tokens on the statements they believe the most, before discussing why they made their choices. They will realise, independently or by being guided, that without context or further information, their gut reaction might not always be the correct one.
Once the sources of the claims are revealed, participants might be surprised to realise they change their minds about what they believe. Can we trust advertisements and celebrities to give us impartial advice about what products to buy? How do we know that a newspaper article is getting all the facts right? This exercise will make the group think about who is making the claim they see online, and whether their motives are trustworthy.
How easy is it to know good evidence when we see it? This exercise looks at what we consider ‘good evidence’. For each of the claims they’ve just been discussing, the participants will be given a set of articles that may or may not provide evidence to support that claim, ranging from personal testimonies to rigorous scientific studies. The exercise involves ranking the items by how strong the evidence is and matching items to the claim they support.
Now the participants have learned when to ask for evidence and what evidence looks like, they will learn how to find the evidence (or perhaps identify a lack of evidence) behind a claim. Following on from discussions about what we consider good evidence, the participants will think about where we can go to find out whether relevant evidence exists.
Equipped with new skills in evidence hunting, participants who are keen to complete the full challenge will now go off on their own to investigate claims they find on social networks, in advertising or in the media. Those who choose to take on this challenge will be required to present their findings to a leader in a following session in order to become an Evidence Hunter.